Our Predictions
Both teams have shown strong attacking ability and defensive gaps recently. Cincinnati have scored in 4 of their last 5 at home; Columbus netted 4 goals last game. With the odds at 1.50, bookmakers expect goals on both sides.
These teams’ matches are often open, with plenty of chances. The last encounter ended 4-0, and both are playoff-minded. At 1.57, the odds suggest a likely goal-fest, especially with key defenders missing.
Cincinnati has great form at home, winning 4 of their last 5. They will be motivated to bounce back after the heavy loss, while Columbus has shown vulnerabilities away. At 2.35, there’s good value for the home win, especially in a tight playoff tie.
Accumulator odds
Extratips Match Preview: FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew – MLS Playoffs Showdown
Welcome back to Extratips for what promises to be a fierce MLS playoff clash! FC Cincinnati welcomes Columbus Crew on November 8, 2025, at 23:00. With both teams eyeing a spot in the next round, expect drama at TQL Stadium. The bookies have FC Cincinnati as slight favorites at 2.35, with the Crew at 2.75, and a draw offered at 3.60.
Cincinnati holds home advantage but Columbus hammered them 4-0 in the last meeting, powered by an early red card for Yuya Kubo. Historically, Columbus leads the H2H with 8 wins to Cincinnati’s 5 (last 5: Columbus 3 wins, Cincinnati 2), but Cincinnati have had the upper hand at home. In recent home games, Cincinnati have won 4, lost 1; Columbus has managed 1 win, 2 draws, and 2 losses in their last 5 away.
Key absences include Brad Smith and Matt Miazga for Cincinnati, with Columbus missing Mohamed Farsi and Wessam Abou Ali. Motivations are high – Cincinnati look to bounce back and leverage home support, while Columbus want to build on their dominant last performance. A classic rivalry, tactical tweaks and playoff nerves add spice. Keep an eye on early goals and tempers flaring. With firepower on both sides and both teams eager to prove a point, expect goals and drama under the lights.